鄭直在唐朝歷史百科2011-11-27提出五種理由, 認為唐朝並非真正「以胖為美」 本器黃玉雕琢, 鳳眼, 瓜子臉, 櫻桃嘴, 這樣的美女顛覆了「以胖為美」 的唐代美女看法.本器有擴散暈沁色, 溶蝕孔及鈣化現象明顯.Carve with yellow jade, the eyes like those of a phoenix, the lip like the cherry the face has the shape of a melon seed, this is the most beautiful lady in the Chinese jade ever found. Antiquity evidence of dissolved pits, calcification, and diffusive markings are presented.
- quality of jade: 8
- rareness: 10
- historical and cultural significance: 9
- workmanship: 10
- condition: 9